Written By JR Robinson

The Memphis-Shelby County public schools have long been a topic of passionate conversation in our community. This week, the Shelby County Commission is considering a proposal that could shake up the leadership of the school board: cutting the current four-year terms of five elected school board members down to just two years.

It’s a change that would mean more frequent elections, faster turnover, and a potential shift in how education is governed in Memphis. Supporters see it as a way to keep board members accountable and responsive. Opponents warn it could bring instability where careful, long-term planning is desperately needed.

We took a deep dive into both sides of this debate — because at the heart of it, this is about the future of Memphis’s kids and schools.

The Case for Shorter Terms: Accountability and Fresh Ideas

For many Memphians who’ve felt frustrated with lingering problems in the school district, more frequent elections are a welcome idea.

“Cutting the terms keeps board members on their toes,” says local parent and activist Lisa Hernandez. “When your job depends on voter approval every two years, you have to listen, respond, and fight for our kids in real time — not just coast because your seat is safe for four years.”

Advocates argue that two-year terms will:

• Increase responsiveness: Board members must be more engaged with constituents, ready to adapt as needs change and challenges arise.

• Motivate fresh leadership: Shorter terms encourage new candidates and ideas, helping prevent stagnation and complacency.

• Prevent entrenched power: Long terms may allow some officials to become too comfortable or disconnected from community demands.

Supporters see this as an opportunity to bring energy and accountability back to the board — which has struggled with test scores, funding challenges, and governance controversies for years.

The Case Against: Stability and Long-Term Vision Matter

On the other side, many educators, community leaders, and parents urge caution.

“Education is a marathon, not a sprint,” explains veteran teacher and union representative Marcus Ellis. “Good school reform requires time — to build trust, craft policies, and see strategies through. Two years just isn’t enough time to do this right.”

Critics warn that shorter terms may:

• Disrupt continuity: School boards need stability to follow through on long-term plans for improving achievement and equity.

• Create constant campaigning: Board members spending time raising funds and campaigning every other year risks pulling focus from the complex work of education governance.

• Discourage qualified candidates: The pressure of back-to-back campaigns and the perception of a lack of job security could deter experienced, serious leaders from running.

They caution that in a district facing persistent challenges, continuity and experience on the board may be more important than frequent turnover.

What Memphis Voters Need to Consider

So, what’s the right move for Memphis? This is about more than just elections — it’s about how we want our public schools to be led in the years ahead.

• Do we value agility and immediate accountability, trusting that new voices and more frequent elections will drive progress?

• Or do we prioritize steady leadership and planning, recognizing that education reform is a slow, complex process requiring patience?

The Shelby County Commission must weigh these competing concerns carefully. The decision will send a strong message about how seriously Memphis takes the future of its students.

We Want to Hear From You

What do you think about cutting school board terms in half? Would shorter terms bring Memphis better schools, or just more election noise?

Drop your thoughts below, or reach out on social media with #MemphisSchoolBoardTerms. This is a community conversation — and your voice matters as we shape the future of our schools.

Final Thought

No matter where you land, one thing is clear: Memphians care deeply about our public schools. Whether through shorter terms or longer ones, the goal should always be the same — better education and brighter opportunities for every child in this city.

Let’s keep this conversation going, with respect, passion, and a shared commitment to Memphis’s future.

If you'd like, I can also help you with social media posts or a follow-up piece highlighting local voices. Just let me know!